If
you don't want to read nit-picking, read no further. Suncompass acknowledges that she has put The Rat Patrol episodes under a magnifying glass in a way that the series' creators could never have envisioned. Although the items Suncompass has picked at have fulfilled the need in a series more focussed on action than accuracy, there are times when, in Suncompass's opinion, it might have been just as easy and just as much fun to have got it 'right'. [][][][][] Probably the biggest historical bomb in The Rat Patrol is the implication that the American Army was in charge of the wartime desert patrols in North Africa, and that the British and the Commonwealth had no role in them or in their considerable successes. This particular presentation caused the British government of the days when Rat Patrol was aired considerable indignation. As a result, the series was subsequently pulled from British airwaves.
Manipulation of history is not unheard of in the world of television. Kill or be Killed Raid
The
episode
mission briefing
Col. Schweiger points out that a source of water would allow them - the Germans - to outflank the enemy and possibly win the war in North Africa. From his motions on the map it is clear that the front must lie within Tunisia. Only in the final few months of the war in North Africa did the front fall within that country. With the Americans coming at them from the west, the Free French from the southwest and the British from the south, the Germans were trapped against the Mediterranean and were ultimately pushed up to Cap Bon (at top of map) where they surrendered on May 13, 1943. It is proposed by Suncompass that Col. Schweiger, in his confidence that a water source at that point in the war would have allowed the Germans to defeat the Allies in North Africa, was an overly optimistic fellow. If he had been pointing at a map of Cyrenaica, Suncompass probably wouldn't have nit-picked at him. See Bizerte at the northern edge of Tunisia on the map. That is where Moffitt was going to pay an unhappy visit to the Gestapo had Troy not rescued him in this episode. The Double or Nothing Raid
The
episode mission
briefing
Perhaps of some relevance - in March of 1942 when this episode was set, Rommel and the Afrika Korps had been halted west of a diagonal line at Gazala. Gazala, a coastal town, lies north and west (left) of the red 'X' location (if Jaghbub). The Germans and Italians held the territory to the west of the Gazala-Bir Hakim line while the British and Allied countries held all to the east (right). If the location of the 'X' is approximately accurate (and it would fit with the mentioned date), the spot for the prisoner exchange may have fallen well inside Allied territory. [][][][][]
[][][][][] Oops again Dare Devil Rescue Raid
That ancient Roman road in question had to be over 1500 and probably closer to 2000 years old. Suncompass might forgive Troy's confusion with the word 'century', but Moffitt really ought to have known better (his excuse would no doubt be that he had been a tad upset about his missing father)(is there an excuse for the episode writer though?). The word that our boys would have been wiser to use was 'thousands' or millenia (from Latin for 'thousand'). Two thousand years. Just one site of many with a brief history of Libya: http://www.lonelyplanet.com/destinations/africa/libya/history.htm For a more detailed Libyan history: http://www.countryreports.org/history/libyhist.htm
To
see pictures of some real Roman ruins and genuine Roman roads of
Leptis Magna (an ancient city of Libya): A fun place to explore the major Libyan city of Lepcis Magna as it was in Roman times: http://www.alnpete.co.uk/lepcis/ [][][][][] When did you say you last saw David? Field of Death Raid
The nit-picker in Suncompass wonders just where and when that photograph (above) was supposed to have been taken. We are told that Sam and David hadn't seen each other since war was declared. Was the photo really taken before the war? In the photo we see Sam Troy (in his Rat Patrol 'uniform') standing in the desert next to David who is garbed in what looks like an RAF uniform. It seems fair, therefore, to assume David had already joined the RAF when the photograph was taken. If they'd just put them into 'civvies' for the photograph, Suncompass would not have had a nit-pickin' leg to stand on. |
[][][][][]
B-Negative Raid
The
episode mission briefing |
|
The problem for our lads seemed to lie in the fact that Moffitt needed a transfusion of blood and none of his patrol mates had the same blood type. On the surface this seems to be a serious problem, but in actual fact it isn't. If Troy, with type A blood, had donated to Moffitt it would have been very serious indeed and probably would have killed Moffitt. But Hitch and Tully, with their type O blood, are what are termed 'Universal Donors'. Type O blood has no surface antigens on the blood cells so either Hitch or Tully could have safely given blood to Moffitt or Troy, or anyone with one of the other blood groups - be that A, AB, B or O. But, you ask, what about that Rh-negative factor in Moffitt's blood? The other fellows all had Rh-positive blood. Doesn't that matter? |
According to the web site below, the answer to that question is that even with the Rh-negative factor Moffitt probably could have had a transfusion from Hitch or Tully and probably suffered no lasting or long term effects. Of course our lads didn't known all that stuff about blood so they fearlessly ventured into danger to find a donor in the German camp. If they had known Hitch and Tully could have given blood to Moffitt then they wouldn't have gone to Dietrich looking for help and then found Fabian. Although it would have been much easier to just let Tully or Hitch donate the blood, the episode would have been much shorter and wouldn't have been anything like as much fun for the viewer. (and Fabian might still be with the Germans) If the writer of the episode had only givenTully and Hitch blood types A and/or AB then Suncompass couldn't have nitpicked here. |
Suncompass thinks it is a darn good idea to always have a couple of people with type O blood in a patrol. You'd have a handy donor compatible for any of your wounded if you needed one.
And something else about this episode that Suncompass has been considering (don't sigh. You didn't have to read this if you didn't want to) ....given that the Rh component in blood was only identified in 1940, would our lads necessarily have known their Rh factor? (A vet that Suncompass asked said that his dogtags included his blood type, but not the Rh factor.) And would Dietrich really have been so very 'up' on the discovery of the Rh factor and the relative commonness of the negative factor?
For
more about blood transfusions, including the impact of the Rh factor
in transfusions [about half way down in the section and called
Delayed hemolytic reactions] :
http://web.archive.org/web/20030413071444/http://anesthesiologyinfo.com/articles/06232002.php
[Note:
the above url is currently only accessible through the archiving
facilities of archive.org. The page may be slow to load.]
[many thanks to NG for locating the above link and explaining the 'bloody' stuff to Suncompass]
[][][][][]
Oops too. Is that a microphone boom I see?
Field of Death Raid
|
The
episode mission briefing |
[][][][][]
Who is that and what is he doing on top of the electrician's van?
The Two if By Sea Raid
|
The
episode mission briefing
|
Do you have a date?
The Gunrunner Raid
|
The
episode mission briefing (Suncompass is sure you know what their answer will be) |
In the scene pictured above Ned says, "This is what we might call Exhibit A. A United States Army Air Force flying jacket, circa November 1942. Belonging to one Edwin 'Ned' Cunningham. Fourteen missions over North Africa..."
Suncompass does not quibble with his November 1942 date. That date fits history. The problem arises with the other dates Ned quoted earlier in the same scene when he was complaining about times when the Rat Patrol had destroyed his armaments destined for sale to the Germans. Those dates he quoted? August 11, September 4, and September 27.
If Ned was shot down circa November 1942 as he said, then it would stand to reason that he got into the gunrunning business with the Germans in North Africa AFTER that time. Therefore August 11, September 4, and September 27 must all have been in 1943. It is a wonder Ned could find any Germans in North Africa on those dates in any position to purchase anything because the war in North Africa ended in May 1943. Any remaining Germans would have been in POW camps.
If only Ned had said the pesky Rat Patrol raids had happened in January, February, March or April. Then Suncompass might have let it go.
[][][][][]
And just where is your hat, Dietrich?
The Violent Truce Raid
|
The
episode mission briefing: |
According to Paul Brickhill, author of The Great Escape (classified as fiction but recounts the true story of a mass escape from a German POW camp.), Dietrich, technically not in full uniform, should not have saluted the British officer. A quotation from the book:
For
more about the real Great Escape - the real POWs; who made it and
who didn't; the conditions; the plan; the tunnels; the conditions;
the guards and murderers, as well as how the 1963 movie of the same
name compares to reality - check out this excellent site: Thanks to J.W. for pointing out this Oops. [][][][][] Only the shadow knows The Blind Man's Bluff Raid
Troy collapses onto the sand more than once. Here we see him on the sand but to his left we see a distinctly unnatural-looking shadow. What is casting that shadow? His ultimate captors? If so, why was Troy free to get up and stagger about more in the next scene? Suncompass suspects it was likely one of the filming crew, possibly even the cameraman, getting in for a tight shot. But only the shadow will know for sure. Thanks to C.L.W. and S.E. for spotting this Oops. [][][][][] "Take a load off whenever you can, I always say." - Suncompass The Delilah Raid
Thanks to the W.C.R. and S.E. for picking up this Oops. [][][][][] Excuse me, sir, where did you say they were meeting? The Fifth Wheel Raid
Tunis? Tunis is the capital city of Tunisia and is located near the northern tip of the country (see the map above). As history would have it, when Tunis was in the hands of the Allies then almost everything in North Africa was in Allied hands - for Tunis was captured by the Allies on May 7, 1943, literally days before all German forces in North Africa surrendered (May 13th). Suncompass wonders where the Colonel could have been going after his Tunis meeting that took him (not on the coast road we are told) through German-held territory? This makes Suncompass scratch her head. That late in the war, the Germans still in North Africa had been squished up against the Mediterranean Sea in the extreme northeastern part of Tunisia (see Cape Bon on the map) so was it likely they were roaming about (not on the coast road) south of Tunis and kidnapping colonels where the Allied forces had taken control? Suncompass thinks not and respectfully suggests that the secret meeting was so secret that even Boggs wasn't told where it really was being held. If only Boggs had said Tripoli or Tobruk or even Timbuktoo, Suncompass would (probably) have kept her nit-picking thoughts to herself. [][][][][]
If
nit-picking is your joy, check out the odd 'oops' brought to light
in the [][][][][]
If
you think you've seen an 'oops' in the series, let Suncompass check
it out. |
Suncompass maintains that flaws in no way diminish enjoyment of the series.
In fact, some even make the series more entertaining.
Almost
forty years after its creation, The Rat Patrol still packs a
tank-sized wallop of entertainment - just as it was meant to do.
Above
all, enjoy watching!
[][][][][]
website
designed and authored by Suncompass (suncompass@fandom.tv)
queries,
comments, suggestions, corrections welcome
Page
last updated April 12, 2005
©2003-2010
Suncompass